The only improvement over the current system, would be for it to be compulsory (within reason) to pm who you have awarded or removed karma from.
Only my thought though.
James

While i was snooping around the SDH Forum, bored at an early time in the morning.
I came across the forum information near to the bottom of the page, and it has things like,
last post....
latest member....
Then theres a link to "karma stats" And in there you can find the following table;

And here's where you can find it; http://www.southerndownhill.com/forum/index.php?action=viewkarma
If you notice the section of "For what" It states "Explanation was disabled"


Basically the point of this post is that there is an option to give a reason as to what an individual has given to another, Just people choose not too.
So no more comments about "There should be a system where individuals explain, what and or why they gave you 'such and such' karma" 

Chris

We disable the ability to give a reason, because it would be required and would go against the original reason people asked for karma.

Ah, alright. I was mistaken.

In that case, apologies for posting it up